Poll: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
TOMMY (THE WHO)
THE WALL (PINK FLOYD)
JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR (RICE & LLOYD WEBBER)
QUADROPHENIA (THE WHO)
JOE'S GARAGE ACTS 1-3 (FRANK ZAPPA)
ARTHUR (DECLINE & FALL OF BRITISH EMPIRE) (THE KINKS)
OPERATION MINDCRIME (QUEENSRYCHE)
THE LAMB LIES DOWN ON BROADWAY (GENESIS)
S.F. SORROW (THE PRETTY THINGS
OTHER (Please State)
[Show Results]
 
 
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
07-22-2011, 04:18 AM,
#1
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Rock Operas.. you either love them or hate them. Which has been the best ?
....
Reply
07-22-2011, 07:31 AM,
#2
 
Joe's Garage is without doubt one of the greatest albums of all time. icon_cheers.gif

Down in Joe's Garage
We didn't have no dope or LSD
But a coupla quartsa beer
Reply
07-22-2011, 10:38 AM,
#3
 
Darran Wrote:Joe's Garage is without doubt one of the greatest albums of all time. icon_cheers.gif

Down in Joe's Garage
We didn't have no dope or LSD
But a coupla quartsa beer
Yes, I agree. I used to listen to Frank Zappa a lot and Joe's Garage is a classic.
Alice Cooper "Goes To Hell" however, proves that even the best can get it wrong.
....
Reply
08-26-2011, 08:25 AM,
#4
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
+ 1 for Joe's garage.

Tommy also has solid songs.

And I can't stand Pink Floyd music though I admit the guitar solo from "Another Brick..." is remarkable.
I don't like living in this fleshy human shell
As much as I abuse it it's really gone to hell
Reply
08-26-2011, 09:43 AM,
#5
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
The Pros And Cons Of Hitch-hiking - Roger Waters
The Hazzards Of Love - The Decemberists

Quite infectious story telling music as well.
All things must pass
Reply
08-26-2011, 05:08 PM,
#6
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Green Day's American Idiot! But I voted for Jesus Christ Super Star. I listened to it so many times as a kid, and it's really so incredible.
Go Completely Wild!
Reply
08-26-2011, 06:50 PM,
#7
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Phantom of the Opera. Incredible, especially live on Broadway!
Reply
08-27-2011, 05:22 PM,
#8
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
operation mindcrime is one of the greatest records ever written .
the wall was pretty good too . too bad queensryce has put out some very bad stuff out the last 10 years or so . i just picked up the latest from queensryce and liked more than the covers disc and american soldier
which i couldn't stand one song on either disc . and i used to be a big fanatic about that band . i just shocked at how weak thier songs have become . oh well !! HuhHuh
Reply
09-05-2011, 07:24 PM,
#9
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Thick as a Brick,
the greatest album by anyone, anywhere,
IMO
Reply
09-06-2011, 07:19 PM,
#10
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Quadrophenia for The Ox's bass playing alone.
Reply
09-07-2011, 01:36 AM,
#11
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
(09-06-2011, 07:19 PM)CheapRick Wrote: Quadrophenia for The Ox's bass playing alone.


I would certainly like to agree 100 %!!!!

Mr. Entwistle / his playing/ his tone / his songs...!!
"The Real Me"!!!
Reply
10-30-2011, 09:45 PM,
#12
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Rocky Horror Picture Show. A classic opera with a tragic ending.
Cheap Trick fan since 1977

"We got off the plane and thought, 'Man, there's somebody real famous here.' And then we found out it was us." - Rick Nielsen
Reply
11-01-2011, 05:12 PM,
#13
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
(08-27-2011, 05:22 PM)t5RageForOrder Wrote: operation mindcrime is one of the greatest records ever written .
the wall was pretty good too . too bad queensryce has put out some very bad stuff out the last 10 years or so . i just picked up the latest from queensryce and liked more than the covers disc and american soldier
which i couldn't stand one song on either disc . and i used to be a big fanatic about that band . i just shocked at how weak thier songs have become . oh well !! HuhHuh

I also voted for Operation Mindcrime by Queensryche. That is a f!@#ing BRILLIANT hard rock/heavy metal concept album. The song writing and musicianship are both phenomenal...dark, moody, experimental, blistering,...and all the songs fit together perfectly.
Sadly, Operation Mindcrime II was a desperate attempt to recreate a once in a lifetime masterpiece. It should have been left alone.

As a long time fan of Queensryche, I think they really miss Chris DeGarmo. The other problem is that they jumped the shark with Silent Lucidity and Empire outsold Mindcrime. After that, they were trying too hard for another crossover hit and they lost a bit of their core identity. They have always had some slow songs but never a lullaby. That was the beginning of a downward spiral.

Bye-bye, so long, farewell, bye-bye, so long, sayonara, bye-bye, au revoir, Auf Wiedersehen,
JCC

"I Want You to ROCK YOUR SPEECH!!!"
Reply
11-03-2011, 08:57 AM, (This post was last modified: 11-03-2011, 08:58 AM by Debbie Lowe.)
#14
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
Love, love, love "Jesus Christ Superstar" and still listen to it all the time but I've never thought of it in the same category with the likes of "Tommy" or "Quadrophenia.

I just saw Roger Daltrey perform "Tommy" a few weeks ago and it was amazing. I've always said that The Who is my second all-time favorite band. I've also always said that I think Pete Townshend is a true musical genius, like a modern day Mozart or something. I spent so many hours growing up in the 70's, laying in my bedroom with the headphones on and just listenting to "Tommy" over and over. I know every beat and nuance to every song and I guess that's why I'm partial to it.

Debbie Lowe
"Thought no one could hear me, I was goin' insane...!"
"Dance, dance, dance across the floor, a lust for life I've never seen before"
Reply
11-08-2011, 04:23 PM,
#15
RE: Rock Operas. - ..Kilroy was here...
2112.

Maybe a little "short" for a rock opera, but it counts in my book.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)